A Field Test of Three Great Portable Heaters for Winter Emergencies: Which Kept Me Warmest?

Last February, when the grid went down for 18 hours during a brutal ice storm, I realized my emergency heating setup needed serious work. My family huddled under blankets while the house dropped to 43 degrees. Never again.

I decided to field test three different types of portable heaters over the next few months. Not just read specs or watch YouTube reviews, but actually use them in real cold weather scenarios. Here's what I discovered.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links, which means I earn a commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you.

My Testing Setup and Conditions

I tested each heater in my unheated garage during three separate cold snaps in March. Temperatures ranged from 28 to 35 degrees Fahrenheit. The garage is roughly 240 square feet with standard insulation.

For each test, I started with the garage at ambient outdoor temperature. I ran each heater for two hours and measured temperature changes every 30 minutes using a digital thermometer placed six feet from the heat source.

Safety was my top priority. I kept a window cracked for ventilation during propane and kerosene tests, and I had a carbon monoxide detector running throughout.

Test #1: The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy

This propane heater is everywhere in prepper circles, so it had to be part of my test. The Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Heater puts out 9,000 BTUs and runs on standard one-pound propane canisters.

Mr. Heater Portable Buddy Heater

Setup and Initial Impressions

Assembly took about five minutes. The built-in safety features impressed me right away - tip-over protection, low oxygen sensor, and automatic shut-off. It lit easily with the built-in piezo igniter.

The heat output was immediate and noticeable. Within ten minutes, I could feel the warmth from across the garage.

Performance Results

Starting temperature: 31°F

• 30 minutes: 38°F

• 60 minutes: 45°F

• 90 minutes: 51°F

• 120 minutes: 56°F

Temperature gain: 25 degrees in two hours

The Buddy heated the space evenly and consistently. One pound propane canister lasted the full two-hour test with fuel to spare. The manufacturer claims 5.5 hours of runtime on high heat, which matched my experience.

Pros and Cons

Advantages:

• Fast, powerful heat output

• Multiple safety features

• Simple operation

• Widely available fuel

• No electricity required

Drawbacks:

• Propane creates moisture (condensation on garage windows)

• Fuel canisters add up in cost

• Requires ventilation for safety

• Takes up floor space

Test #2: The EcoFlow Wave 2 Battery-Powered Heater

Electric heaters usually need grid power, but this battery-powered unit caught my attention.

The EcoFlow Wave Portable Air Conditioner and Heater runs off its internal battery or can connect to portable power stations.

 The EcoFlow Wave Portable Air Conditioner and Heater

Setup and Initial Impressions

This thing is hefty at 34 pounds, but the wheels made it manageable. The setup was plug-and-play simple. The LED display shows battery level, temperature settings, and runtime estimates.

The modern design felt out of place in my garage test, but I appreciated the precise temperature control.

Performance Results

Starting temperature: 33°F

• 30 minutes: 37°F

• 60 minutes: 42°F

• 90 minutes: 47°F

• 120 minutes: 50°F

Temperature gain: 17 degrees in two hours

The battery died at the 118-minute mark, just shy of my two-hour target. Heat output was steady but gentler than the propane unit. The integrated fan helped distribute warm air more evenly than I expected.

Pros and Cons

Advantages:

• No fuel or ventilation requirements

• Precise temperature control

• Quiet operation

• Also functions as air conditioner

• Clean, no emissions

Drawbacks:

• Limited runtime on battery

• Slower heat output

• Expensive upfront cost

• Heavy and bulky

• Complex electronics could fail

Test #3: The Dyna-Glo Kerosene Heater

Kerosene heaters are old school, but they work when everything else fails.

I tested the Dyna-Glo WK11C8 Indoor Kerosene Convection Heater rated for spaces up to 500 square feet.

Setup and Initial Impressions

This required the most setup time. I had to install the wick, prime the system, and adjust the flame height properly. The learning curve was steeper than the other two heaters.

The smell of kerosene was noticeable during startup, but it faded as the unit warmed up. Build quality felt solid and simple not much to break.

Dyna-Glo WK11C8 Indoor Kerosene Convection Heater

Performance Results

Starting temperature: 29°F

• 30 minutes: 39°F

• 60 minutes: 48°F

• 90 minutes: 55°F

• 120 minutes: 61°F

Temperature gain: 32 degrees in two hours

This was the clear winner for raw heat output. The convection design heated the air more evenly than I expected. One gallon of kerosene lasted the full test with plenty remaining.

Pros and Cons

Advantages:

• Highest heat output

• Long runtime per fuel tank

• Kerosene stores well long-term

• Simple, reliable technology

• Works in power outages

Drawbacks:

• Strong fuel odor during operation

• Requires manual lighting and adjustment

• Needs regular wick maintenance

• Must store fuel safely

• Produces some indoor air pollution

Real-World Practical Considerations

After three months of occasional use, here's what matters most in actual emergencies:

Fuel Availability and Storage

Propane canisters are everywhere, but they're expensive for regular use. Kerosene is cheaper per BTU and stores indefinitely, but finding it requires planning ahead.

The battery heater is convenient until the power dies. If you have a solar generator or backup power system, it becomes more practical.

Safety in Confined Spaces

All three require different safety considerations. The battery heater is safest for truly enclosed spaces. Propane and kerosene both need ventilation, which reduces their heating efficiency.

Setup Time During Emergencies

When your power goes out at 2 AM in a blizzard, simplicity matters. The Mr. Heater Buddy wins here - it's ready to go in under a minute. The kerosene heater requires the most preparation and skill.

My Verdict: Which emergency portable heater actually won?

For pure heating performance, the kerosene heater dominated. It raised the temperature 32 degrees in two hours and would have kept going all night on one tank of fuel.

But heating performance isn't everything in emergency preparedness.

For most preppers, I recommend the Mr. Heater Portable Buddy. It offers the best balance of heat output, ease of use, and safety features. The 25-degree temperature gain was substantial, and the built-in safety systems give me confidence using it around family.

The battery heater works best if you already have a robust backup power system. It's the safest option for indoor use, but the limited runtime and high cost make it a specialized choice.

The kerosene heater is ideal for longer-term heating scenarios where you can properly ventilate the space. It's the most economical to operate and provides serious heat output.

Essential Safety Reminders

Never operate propane or kerosene heaters in completely sealed spaces. Carbon monoxide kills silently.

Keep fire extinguishers accessible when using any emergency heater. Test your carbon monoxide detectors regularly.

Practice setting up and operating your chosen heater before you need it in an emergency. Fumbling with unfamiliar equipment in the dark and cold is dangerous.

Building Your Winter Emergency Kit

Your emergency heating solution should match your specific situation. Urban apartment dwellers have different needs than rural homesteaders.

Consider pairing a primary heater with backup options. I keep the Mr. Heater Buddy as my go-to choice, with emergency blankets and sleeping bags as backups.

Whatever you choose, test it thoroughly before winter arrives. Your family's comfort and safety depend on equipment that works when you need it most.

Category: Gear Reviews Tags: backup heating, portable heater, winter survival, emergency preparedness, off-grid living, tested gear, power outage solutions